Supplier Quote Comparison
Put several suppliers’ quotes for the same item side by side — priced on the quantity you would actually have to buy, MOQ included.
Three quotes for the same product rarely differ only in the unit price. One supplier is cheapest per unit but demands twice the quantity you planned; another includes shipping and a third adds it on top; the fastest quote carries the highest defect rate you have seen from that factory. Comparing them on the sticker price alone picks the wrong winner often enough that the comparison deserves its own table — one that prices every quote on the quantity you would actually have to buy, including the minimum order quantity, and then divides back down to the cost of one good unit.
Quotes for the same item, priced honestly: each quote is costed on the quantity you would actually have to buy — your planned quantity or the supplier’s MOQ, whichever is larger — with shipping spread over those units and your expected defect rate turned into a cost per good unit. Supplier names and prices never leave this page: no account, no storage, no share link, nothing in the URL.
Estimate only — not procurement, financial or legal advice. Every figure above is a figure you entered; verify the winning quote with the supplier in writing before you order. Next in the chain: price the winning quote’s full import cost on the US Landed Cost Calculator, or run the whole chain on the Seller Procurement Workbench.
Data passport — where the figures on this page come from
| Data source | No external reference data — every figure in the comparison (prices, MOQs, lead times, defect rates) is your own entry from quotes you hold |
|---|---|
| Effective | Not applicable |
| Last verified | November 2026 |
| Watch owner | No external data to watch — this page ships no built-in rates or reference data; the figures are the ones you enter |
Quick answers
How do you compare supplier quotes fairly when the MOQs differ?
Price every quote on the quantity you would actually have to buy — the larger of your planned quantity and that supplier’s MOQ — then compare the totals and divide back: effective unit cost = order total ÷ units actually bought. A $1.12 quote with an 8,000-unit MOQ costs $8,960 when you planned 5,000; a $1.20 quote with a 1,000-unit MOQ costs $6,450 for the 5,000 you wanted.
Both figures matter and they answer different questions. The effective unit cost tells you what each unit really costs you after MOQ and shipping; the total tells you the cheque you actually write and the stock you will be holding. This page shows both, plus the cost per good unit after your expected defect rate, because the cheapest unit price can still be the most expensive order.
What is the cost per good unit, and why does the defect rate change the ranking?
Cost per good unit = effective unit cost ÷ (1 − defect rate). It spreads the order total over only the units you expect to sell. At a 2.5% defect rate a $1.1200 effective cost becomes $1.1487 per good unit; at 0.5% a $1.3740 cost becomes $1.3809 — defects narrow or widen the gap between quotes, and at closer prices they flip the ranking.
The adjustment assumes a defective unit is a total loss. If a supplier replaces defects free or refunds them, your real figure sits between the effective unit cost and the per-good-unit cost — which is itself a point worth raising in the negotiation, and a reason the two columns sit side by side here.
Why is there no share link or saved history for my quote comparison?
Because supplier names and prices are business data. URLs end up in browser history, shared chats and server logs, so this page never puts your figures in one — there is no share link at all. The comparison lives in page memory and leaves only as a CSV file or printout you choose to make.
That is the seller cluster’s standing rule on this site: inputs are never uploaded, never written to localStorage or IndexedDB, and never carried in a link. If you need the table somewhere else, download the CSV — the file is yours and travels only where you carry it.
How to use
- Name the item and enter the quantity you plan to order — every quote is priced on that quantity, or on its MOQ when the MOQ is larger.
- Type each quote in (supplier, unit price, MOQ, lead time, shipping per order, expected defect rate, payment terms), or import a CSV with those columns — the file is read on your device only.
- Read the comparison table: quantity you would actually buy, goods, total, effective cost per unit and cost per good unit, with the lowest unit cost, lowest total and fastest lead time flagged.
- Add or remove quotes (2 to 8) until the shortlist is the one you are really choosing between.
- Download the table as CSV or print it for the order file. Nothing is saved on the site — closing the page clears the comparison.
About this tool
That is what this page does. For each quote it works out the quantity you would actually buy (the larger of your planned quantity and the supplier’s MOQ), the goods total, the order total with shipping, the effective unit cost — total divided by units actually bought — and the cost per good unit, which spreads the order total over only the units you expect to be sellable. The summary then names three different winners on purpose: lowest effective unit cost, lowest total outlay, and shortest lead time are often three different suppliers, and a good sourcing decision knows which of the three it is optimising.
Quotes can be typed in one by one or imported from a CSV file you already have — a header row naming the columns (supplier, price, MOQ, lead time, shipping, defect rate, terms) is enough, and the file is parsed on your device. The finished table exports back out as CSV or prints as a clean sheet for the order file.
Supplier names and prices are the clearest case of business data this site handles, so this page is strict even by the seller cluster’s standards: everything lives in page memory only, nothing is written to browser storage, there is deliberately no share link and nothing ever enters a URL — a copied link can therefore never carry your quotes into a chat, a browser history or a server log. The only copies that persist are the CSV or printout you choose to make.
How it works
Quantity bought = max(planned quantity, MOQ). Goods = quantity bought × unit price. Order total = goods + shipping per order. Effective unit cost = order total ÷ quantity bought — this is the number the sticker price hides whenever an MOQ or a shipping charge is in play.
Cost per good unit = effective unit cost ÷ (1 − defect rate ÷ 100). It answers "what does one sellable unit cost me?" under the assumption that defective units are a total loss; supplier replacements or refunds put your real figure between the two unit-cost columns.
Payment terms are carried into the table as text and deliberately not priced: the page does not discount future payments or model financing costs, because the right rate for that is your own cost of capital, not a number a comparison page should invent.
Worked examples
Three quotes for one mug — the page defaults: Ceramic mug 350 ml, planned quantity 5,000. Supplier A: $1.20, MOQ 1,000, 20 days, $450 shipping, 1.0% defects → buy 5,000, goods $6,000.00, total $6,450.00, effective $1.2900, per good unit $1.3030. Supplier B: $1.12, MOQ 8,000, 35 days, shipping included, 2.5% defects → the MOQ binds, buy 8,000, total $8,960.00, effective $1.1200, per good unit $1.1487. Supplier C: $1.35, MOQ 500, 7 days, $120 shipping, 0.5% defects → buy 5,000, total $6,870.00, effective $1.3740, per good unit $1.3809. Lowest unit cost B, lowest total A, fastest C — three winners, one decision.
Importing quotes you already have: Export your shortlist from a spreadsheet as CSV with a header row — supplier, price, moq, lead time, shipping, defect rate, terms — and import it here: each row becomes a quote card with the same maths as typed entries, and the comparison table rebuilds instantly. The file never leaves your device.
Reading the comparison — the columns and what moves them
| Column | How it is worked out | What moves it |
|---|---|---|
| Quantity bought | max(planned quantity, MOQ) | A high MOQ silently enlarges the order |
| Effective cost per unit | (goods + shipping) ÷ quantity bought | Shipping per order; MOQ dilution |
| Cost per good unit | effective cost ÷ (1 − defect rate) | Expected defects; replacement policy |
| Total outlay | goods + shipping, at the quantity bought | The cash decision — stock you must hold counts |
Data passport for this page: no external reference data — every figure is your own entry, so there is no rate table to verify or watch. Last verified: November 2026 (the comparison maths, checked against the worked example above).
Frequently asked questions
Where do my supplier names and prices go?
Nowhere. They are held in this page’s memory while you work and are gone when you close or refresh it. They are never sent to a server, never written to browser storage (no localStorage, no IndexedDB), and never placed in a URL — this page has no share link by design. The only copies that persist are the CSV or printed sheet you explicitly make.
Can I compare quotes in different currencies?
Not on this page — every price is read as USD, and mixing currencies without a dated exchange rate would make the table quietly wrong. Convert each quote to USD at the rate your bank or payment provider would actually give you on the payment date, note the rate in the terms field, and then compare.
Why does the MOQ change the total so much?
Because you have to buy it. When a supplier’s MOQ is above your planned quantity, the comparison prices the MOQ quantity — the extra stock is real money out and real units on your shelf, even when the unit price looks better. If you can genuinely sell the extra units, raise the planned quantity to match and compare again on that basis.
What defect rate should I enter?
Your own evidence: the defect share from your last inspection with that supplier (the AQL Calculator’s inspection sheet is built for exactly that record), or the supplier’s stated rate if you have no history — treated as optimistic. With no evidence at all, leave 0 and read the per-good-unit column as equal to the effective cost, knowing quality is then an untested assumption in every quote.
Does the cheapest quote win?
The page refuses to say — deliberately. It flags the lowest effective unit cost, the lowest total outlay and the shortest lead time separately, because they are different optimisations: unit economics, cash committed, and how soon you can sell. Payment terms (a deposit in advance versus net-30) move the real answer again, which is why they are printed in the table even though they are not priced.
Can this page pull quotes from a marketplace or message suppliers?
No. It has no supplier database, sends nothing anywhere and contacts nobody. It compares the quotes you already hold — which also means it cannot check that a quote is genuine, current, or from the business it claims to be. Do that diligence outside the maths.
First time embedding? Read the step-by-step guide →
More free tools
Reorder Point & Safety Stock Calculator
From average daily demand, its spread, lead time and a target service level: the safety stock to hold and the stock level that should trigger the next order.
Seller Procurement Workbench
The whole sourcing chain on one page: carton → container & pallet → totals → landed cost → the price your margin needs, in shared in-page state.
US Landed Cost Calculator
The full cost of an import landed in the US — goods, freight, duty at your rate, MPF, HMF and insurance, totalled and per unit.
A+ Brief Studio
Turn a product photo and your selling points into an Amazon A+ / Shopify product-page creative brief — module copy structure, hero-image storyboard and a comparison outline, generated in your browser.
AQL Calculator
Look up the AQL sampling plan for your lot: code letter, sample size and accept / reject numbers per ANSI/ASQ Z1.4 and ISO 2859-1.
Merchandise Processing Fee Calculator
Estimate the US Merchandise Processing Fee (MPF) on an import entry — FY2027 CBP rates: 0.3464% of value, minimum $34.58, maximum $670.86.